User talk:Oh.nyet

From ChoralWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search


Hello there and welcome to CPDL! Thank you for all your score contributions so far. I've just been reviewing them and found that in all cases, there a couple of problems with the pages. I hope you don't mind me listing them here so you can hopefully avoid them in the future. Firstly, score pages must include the title of the work, followed by the composer's name in parentheses. Where the composer is anonymous (eg. many Medieval works), the work title should be followed by (Anonymous). Where the work has a folk background or has perhaps been altered down the generations by various editors and composers, it is considered "Traditional". Secondly, the composer page (such as Anonymous or Stephen Collins Foster) must have a link on it to the score pages in question. I have marked the pages you have created for cleanup so if you're not sure how to fix them, don't worry, someone else will come along and sort it out.

Unfortunately, I've had to revert your edit to Out of the deep (Henry Aldrich). This is partly because the score you've provided is clearly not the same as the work on the score page and also because your score seems to have a number of problems with it which I hope you would correct before its publication. These are that there is no title, composer, or lyricist listed on the score; there are numerous issues with lyrics colliding with bar lines and note heads; and there seems to be at least one page missing.

If you have any questions or problems with the above, please reply here and I will get back to you as soon as I can. Kind regards --Bobnotts talk 07:28, 19 April 2010 (UTC)