Talk:All creatures now are merry-minded (John Bennet): Difference between revisions

From ChoralWiki

Latest revision as of 01:49, 16 May 2008

How can these two scores possibly be TWO DIFFERENT EDITIONS, when they are absolutely identical?

Vince Brennan:
PDF file: 82,181 bytes, 8 pp
MIDI file: 10,079 bytes, 2'53" duration
Noteworthy file: 3,449 bytes

Marco-cipoo.net:
PDF file: 82,181 bytes, 8 pp
MIDI file: 10,079 bytes, 2'53" duration
Noteworthy file: 3,449 bytes (when unzipped)

Did I miss something on one or other of the sites acknowledging the other's work?

Philip Legge --Pml 15:31:32, 2006-01-12 (PST)

Both scores are indeed identical. Vince Brennan is listed as a contributor to cipoo.net on their website. See the cipoo.net page

-- ChuckGiffen 08:50 CST, 13 January 2006.

I've just merged the two editions into one entry, noting the newer CPDL no. and alternative link. --Bobnotts talk 18:49, 15 May 2008 (PDT)

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
+==Identical editions?==
 How can these two scores possibly be <u>'''TWO DIFFERENT EDITIONS'''</u>, when they are absolutely identical?
@@ Line 11: / Line 12: @@
 Noteworthy file: 3,449 bytes (when unzipped)
-I don't like to suggest plagiarism, but did I miss something on one or other of the sites acknowledging the other's work?
+Did I miss something on one or other of the sites acknowledging the other's work?
 Philip Legge
 --[[User:Pml|Pml]] 15:31:32, 2006-01-12 (PST)
+:Both scores are indeed identical.  Vince Brennan is listed as a contributor to cipoo.net on their website.  See the cipoo.net page
+:[http://www.cipoo.net/fileinfo_e.html General information for all music published here, read carefully].
+:-- [[User:CHGiffen|ChuckGiffen]] 08:50 CST, 13 January 2006.
+::I've just merged the two editions into one entry, noting the newer CPDL no. and alternative link. --[[User:Bobnotts|Bobnotts]] <small>[[User talk:Bobnotts|'''talk''']]</small> 18:49, 15 May 2008 (PDT)