Talk:In the bleak midwinter (Gustav Holst): Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(→redundant to indicate Lyricist?: reply) |
m (will plan to add Lyricist template unless I hear otherwise →redundant to indicate Lyricist?) |
||
Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
In a situation where there is a link to this text, is it redundant to also add a <nowiki>{{Lyricist|Christina Rossetti}}</nowiki> tag to each score description page for Rosetti's text? | In a situation where there is a link to this text, is it redundant to also add a <nowiki>{{Lyricist|Christina Rossetti}}</nowiki> tag to each score description page for Rosetti's text? | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{reply|color=y|level=1|text= | {{reply|color=y|by=[[User:CHGiffen]]|level=1|text= | ||
Hmm, good question. However, the Lyricist template does create a categorization in the Category:<lyricist name> settings, so there does seem to be some point to including the template. The page [[In the Bleak Midwinter]] (a) does not carry the Rossetti name in its title or in any categorization, and (b) lists settings that are not just CPDL editions and seems to serve a somewhat different purpose. What do others think? | Hmm, good question. However, the Lyricist template does create a categorization in the Category:<lyricist name> settings, so there does seem to be some point to including the template. The page [[In the Bleak Midwinter]] (a) does not carry the Rossetti name in its title or in any categorization, and (b) lists settings that are not just CPDL editions and seems to serve a somewhat different purpose. What do others think? | ||
}} | |||
{{reply|by=[[User:Vaarky|Vaarky]] 07:23, 7 March 2010 (UTC)|text= | |||
Anyone else? I will plan to add the Lyricist template if I don't hear otherwise. | |||
}} | }} |
Revision as of 07:23, 7 March 2010
redundant to indicate Lyricist?
| Help |
In a situation where there is a link to this text, is it redundant to also add a {{Lyricist|Christina Rossetti}} tag to each score description page for Rosetti's text? |
|
|