User talk:Roar

Choral mezzo-soprano voicing

Hi Roar. I reverted your edits to Category:2 part choral music and changed the voicing of O sacrum convivium (Franz Liszt) to "SA" rather than "MzA" or "MA" because CPDL doesn't currently recognise mezzo-soprano as a separate voicing for choral works, although it does for solo vocal works. In my experience, it's fairly rare for a soprano not to be able to reach mezzo soprano notes, also very few composers write choral mezzo-soprano parts (even rarer than baritone) so I don't think there's any reason to introduce mezzo-soprano as a choral voice on CPDL. However, if you feel strongly about the subject, please raise your concerns on the wiki BB or on the external forums. I have just reverted your edit to O sacrum convivium (Franz Liszt) again. Please don't change it again unless/until some consensus is reached on the matter. Thanks --Bobnotts talk 22:20, 7 September 2008 (PDT)

Dates of lyricists on score pages

Hi Roar. I've been removing the dates of lyricists that you've been adding to score pages on the basis that if there is a page for a lyricist, his/her dates will be there. Just in the same way that we don't note composers' dates on score pages, nor do we note lyricists' if they have a page of their own. Thanks for all your hard work! --Bobnotts talk 22:09, 2 June 2009 (UTC)